Debt Forgiveness vs
Consolidation Loans: What’s the Difference?


Debt Forgiveness vs Consolidation Loans in Canada

rebuild your worth, book a free consultation todayBook Now

By Taz Rajan | 1573 words | Reading Time: 7 minutes and 51seconds | Last update: 2023/03/13

Are you struggling to make ends meet because of mounting debts? Are you confused about the difference between debt consolidation and debt forgiveness? In this article, we’ll explore the differences between the two financial concepts and their impact on your credit score.

Debt Consolidation Loans: A Comprehensive Overview

A debt consolidation loan refers to a loan or line of credit that rolls your multiple debts, including credit cards and loans, into a single payment. The main goal of debt consolidation is to simplify your debt management process, lower your monthly payments, and reduce your interest rates. With a debt consolidation loan, you’ll have a set interest rate, and one payment to make each month, which is more manageable than making multiple payments with varying interest rates.

Some lenders offer high-interest rate consolidation loans, which may seem like the only option if you have poor credit. However, these loans are not always the best solution as they can end up costing you more in the long run. Before applying for a consolidation loan, ensure you have reviewed the terms, rates, and fees.

To qualify for a consolidation loan, your credit score, income, expenses, assets, and liabilities will be assessed by the lender. If approved, you’ll be bound by the lender's contract to make regular payments, including interest, until you pay off the loan in full.

Pros of Debt Consolidation Loans

  • Simplified debt management process
  • Lower monthly payments and interest rates
  • Suitable for highly disciplined people that won't rack up credit again
  • One-time option for taking advantage of a much lower interest rate and accelerating payments
  • Short-term impact on your credit score

Cons of Debt Consolidation Loans

  • Not suitable for individuals who lack financial discipline
  • Short-term relief from overwhelming and unmanageable debt rather than a permanent solution
  • Not ideal for someone struggling to keep up with new consolidated payments

Impact on Credit Score

Before applying for a debt consolidation loan, remember that the provider will check your credit score, which could impact your credit score initially. The number of inquiries on your credit report has a 10% impact on your overall score. However, making timely payments will help improve your credit score in the long run.

Debt Forgiveness: A Comprehensive Overview

Debt forgiveness refers to having your lenders forgive the debt you owe them or a portion of it. In Canada, there are two debt forgiveness programs: Consumer Proposals and Bankruptcies, both of which are available through federally regulated Licensed Insolvency Trustees.

In a debt forgiveness program, you’ll only pay back a portion of your debts, not 100%, and there's zero interest. The monthly payments are based on your budget and federal guidelines. Debt forgiveness is not a loan or additional credit, and all unsecured debts, including student loans and Canada Revenue Agency debt, can be included in the program.

To qualify for debt forgiveness, you’ll need to attend a consultation with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee firm to review your income, expenses, assets, and liabilities. You’ll also be required to attend two mandatory counselling sessions to help with money mindset and behaviours.

Pros of Debt Forgiveness

  • You only pay a portion of your debts
  • Zero interest
  • Suitable for those struggling with overwhelming and unmanageable debt
  • Debt forgiveness is not a loan or additional credit

Cons of Debt Forgiveness

  • Remains on your credit report for several years
  • Bankruptcy can be costly
  • May impact your future creditworthiness

Impact on Credit Score

Debt forgiveness will remain on your credit report for several years, depending on the type of program you choose. A consumer proposal remains on your credit report for either three years after completion or six years from the file date.

While debt consolidation loans and debt forgiveness are both options for managing overwhelming debt, they differ significantly in their approach and impact on your financial situation.

Debt consolidation loans are a way to combine multiple debts into one payment, usually with a lower interest rate. This can help simplify your finances and make it easier to manage your payments. However, it's important to note that debt consolidation loans do not reduce the amount of debt you owe. You will still need to pay off the full amount of your debts, plus interest, over time.

On the other hand, debt forgiveness programs like consumer proposals and bankruptcies offer a way to reduce the amount of debt you owe, often by a significant amount. These programs are typically only available to individuals who are struggling with unmanageable debt and cannot realistically pay off the full amount. While debt forgiveness can provide relief from overwhelming debt, it also has a significant impact on your credit report and may require you to make significant changes to your financial habits.

Choosing the Right Option for You

If you're struggling with debt, it's important to carefully consider all of your options before making a decision. Debt consolidation loans can be a good choice if you have multiple debts with high interest rates and want to simplify your payments. However, if your debt is overwhelming and you cannot realistically pay it off, debt forgiveness may be a better choice.

It's also important to consider the impact of each option on your credit report. Debt consolidation loans may initially impact your score, but if you make your payments on time, your credit score will gradually improve. Debt forgiveness programs, on the other hand, can have a significant impact on your credit report for several years.

Ultimately, the best way to manage your debt will depend on your individual financial situation and goals. Working with a licensed financial professional can help you evaluate your options and choose the right path forward.

Discuss your options with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee firm like Bromwich+Smith and never  sign into a program or loan in a rush, without ensuring the company you’re  working with is reputable. Bromwich+Smith’s Debt Relief Specialists are available for initial free and confidential consultation by phone at 1-855-884-9243 or request a call back at contact us page.


1- Debt Consolidation vs. Debt Forgiveness: Which One is Right for You?

Debt forgiveness, also known as debt cancellation, is the act of forgiving or canceling some or all of a borrower's outstanding debts. This is typically done by the lender or creditor, and can be done for a variety of reasons such as financial hardship, medical emergency, or as part of a debt relief program. Once the debt is forgiven, the borrower is no longer responsible for repaying that debt.

2- What is a consolidation loan and how is it different from debt forgiveness?

A consolidation loan is a loan that is used to pay off multiple debts, combining them into a single, more manageable payment. The borrower is still responsible for paying off the full amount of the loan, but typically at a lower interest rate and with a longer repayment term than their original debts. Consolidation loans do not forgive or cancel any debt, but rather restructure the debt into a single loan.

3- What are the pros and cons of debt forgiveness compared to consolidation loans?

The main advantage of debt forgiveness is that it allows the borrower to completely eliminate their debt, which can be a huge relief for those struggling with significant financial hardship. However, debt forgiveness may have negative consequences such as damaging the borrower's credit score, and the forgiven debt may be subject to income tax. Consolidation loans can offer lower interest rates and more manageable payment terms, but they still require the borrower to pay off the full amount of their debt.

4- How do I know if debt forgiveness or a consolidation loan is the better option for my financial situation?

The best option will depend on your individual financial situation and the type of debt you have. If you are facing significant financial hardship and are unable to repay your debts, debt forgiveness may be the better option. If you have multiple high-interest debts that you can manage but are struggling with the monthly payments, a consolidation loan may be a better option.

5- Can anyone qualify for debt forgiveness, or are there certain requirements that must be met?

The requirements for debt forgiveness will vary depending on the lender or creditor and the type of debt. Generally, debt forgiveness is more likely to be granted in cases of extreme financial hardship or in special circumstances such as medical emergencies. Some types of debt, such as federal student loans, may have specific programs for debt forgiveness.

6- What types of debt can be forgiven, and what types are eligible for consolidation loans?

Debt forgiveness is typically available for unsecured debts such as credit card debt, medical bills, and personal loans. Some types of debt, such as taxes or secured debts like mortgages, are generally not eligible for debt forgiveness. Consolidation loans can be used for a variety of debts including credit card debt, medical bills, and personal loans.

7- How long does it typically take to complete the debt forgiveness or consolidation loan process?

The length of time will vary depending on the lender or creditor and the type of debt. Debt forgiveness may take several months or even years to complete, while consolidation loans can usually be completed within a few weeks.

8- What impact will debt forgiveness or consolidation loans have on my credit score?

Debt forgiveness may have a negative impact on your credit score, as it typically involves settling debts for less than the full amount owed. Consolidation loans may have a positive impact on your credit score if you make on-time payments and reduce your overall debt-to-income ratio.

9- Are there any tax implications associated with debt forgiveness or consolidation loans?

Debt forgiveness may be subject to income tax, as the forgiven debt may be considered taxable income. Consolidation loans do not have any tax implications.

Credit game chart


By Taz Rajan Community Engagement Partner at Bromwich+Smith
Taz has been in the finance industry for nearly 2 decades and has always been passionate about education and empowerment.  Having declared bankruptcy herself, she intimately understands the shame, stigma surrounding matters of debt as well as the joy and relief that comes from restructuring.  Taz actively works to normalize the conversation of debt through blogs, media interviews, webinars, lunch & learns and through building relationship.


Add new comment

Plain text